Life is embodied network

David George Haskell

We’re all – trees, humans, insects, birds, bacteria – pluralities. Life is embodied network. These living networks are not places of omnibenevolent Oneness. Instead, they are where ecological and evolutionary tensions between cooperation and conflict are negotiated and resolved. These struggles often result not in the evolution of stronger, more disconnected selves but in the dissolution of self into relationship.

The Songs of Trees: Stories from Great Connectors, p. x

Political parties and polarization

The title of a short monograph by Simone Weil makes it pretty clear what she has in mind: On the Abolition of All Political Parties. Spoiler alert – she would like to see them abolished. She wrote the book in 1943 in the final months of her short life. Even though she wrote it over 80 years ago, I think it’s still relevant today.

Weil identifies three essential characteristics of political parties:

Read more

Sophisms past and present

Hannah Arendt:

The most striking difference between ancient and modern sophists is that the ancients were satisfied with a passing victory of the argument at the expense of truth, whereas the moderns want a more lasting victory at the expense of reality. In other words, one destroyed the dignity of human thought whereas the others destroy the dignity of human action. The old manipulators of logic were the concern of the philosopher, whereas the modern manipulators of facts stand in the way of the historian. For history itself is destroyed, and its comprehensibility – based upon the fact that it is enacted by men and therefore to be understood by men – is in danger, whenever facts are no longer held to be part and parcel of the past and present world, and are misused to prove this or that opinion.

Read more

Note to self: Topics and themes to think about

When I started “thinking out loud” almost eighteen months ago I added the tag line writing to see what I think. I hoped that saying that right up front would give me permission to post thoughts even when they weren’t perfectly polished, and even a cursory reading of what’s now on the site makes it clear that I’ve taken advantage of that permission. The writing quality, to put the point charitably, is rather uneven.

Read more

Reading Arendt and Solnit

Earlier this spring I was fortunate to spend several weeks in Germany. I visited with old friends and also traveled around, finding every opportunity I could to practice German. But I had another agenda during my visit: I wanted to learn more about Germany in the 1930s and 1940s and also how Germany itself understands that part of its history. Among other sites, I visited Buchenwald, a museum in Erfurt about the German firm Topf and Sons (which manufactured the crematoria installed in Buchenwald and Auschwitz), the Nuremberg Trial Memorial, and the Stasi museum in Leipzig. Of course I wanted to learn about the history in and of itself, but I was interested even more in how my experience might help me better understand what’s going on in the United States in particular and the world more generally these days. I’m definitely not the first to see some analogies between Germany in the 1930s and the United States today. On the local front, I found some parts of the history of Leipzig from the 19th to the 21st century in Leipzig’s Old Town Hall particularly unsettling as I think now about political and cultural dynamics in several communities that I once thought of as home.

Read more

The power of conversation (and hope)

I was struck by the power of Rebecca Solnit’s comment on the importance of hope in and of itself. But I was also reminded of something I read from Václav Havel many years ago. I can’t find the quotation now, but my recollection is that Havel was asked how he and his compatriots were able to create a democratic government so quickly after years of dictatorship. His response was something like “because we had many conversations over the years even when we knew that talking wouldn’t make any difference.”

Read more

The power of hope

Rebecca Solnit:

Hope is an embrace of the unknown and the unknowable, an alternative to the certainty of both optimists and pessimists. Optimists think it will all be fine without our involvement; pessimists take the opposite position; both excuse themselves from acting. It’s the belief that what we do matters even though how and when it may matter, who and what it may impact, are not things we can know beforehand. We may not, in fact, know them afterward either, but they matter all the same, and history is full of people whose influence was most powerful after they were gone.

Read more

Remembering my mother

There’s a photo sitting on the chest in our bedroom of my mother and me. We’re sitting side by side, probably at our dining room table. The picture is taken from the side so that we’re both in profile. Mom is smiling about something; my own expression is typically deadpan. The picture was taken at our house in Nashville in December, 1999. Our entire family – my parents, my two siblings and their partners, and all of the grandchildren had come together to celebrate my parents’ 50th wedding anniversary. I don’t remember a time before that when we’d all been together; it’s possible that it’s the only time after the birth of all of the grandchildren that we were all in the same place.

Read more

Living without a home

Yesterday I read two different reviews of Claire Messud’s new novel This Strange Eventful History. I’ve added the book to my way-too-tall to-be-read pile. (The pile continues to grow, despite my efforts to read the books in it. I suppose it’s a good thing that life is finite. Otherwise, the number of books in the pile would surely approach infinity.) I’m hoping to read the book someday; for the moment, I’m struck by a description in one of the reviews of a conversation between Barbara and her husband François: “In a moment of frustration, she rebukes him, telling François that he cannot understand her love for home because he has no home.”

Read more

Too many details, not enough story

Facing yet again a long silence from one blog post to the next, I stumbled on this passage from Amit Chaudhuri’s first novel A Strange and Sublime Address. I know that he’s talking about story telling and not blog posting, but I immediately thought of how often I get an idea for a blog post that doesn’t materialize simply because whatever it is that holds the details together in my mind melts away. Perhaps more to the point, I think of my significant other urging me to “Get to the point!” as she listens to me tell a story that she really wants to hear, but also wants to hear it quickly enough to get back to her work.

Read more